Where can I buy Steve's Key Lime Pies in Manhattan? Preferably UWS or UES or Tribeca. (1 reply, last updated by dimples March 6, 2008)

I love key lime pie and have had many in Florida. But Steve's Authentic is my favorite. He uses real key limes from Mexico and the pie is silky smooth, just the right tartness without being too sweet or tart, and the graham crust... (21 replies, last updated by Geo8rge December 15, 2006)

Steve's Authentic Key Lime Pies Pier 41 204 Van Dyke St. Brooklyn, NY 11231 Phone: 718-858-5333 steve@keylime.com Link: http://www.keylime.com (7 replies, last updated by pie June 29, 2004)

Any shops in Park Slope or near a subway line in Brooklyn where I can buy Steve's Key Lime Pies or even a Swingle? I prefer a medium sized pie if possible. (19 replies, last updated by alerievay April 14, 2008)

Following up on a tip from this board, I bought a Steve's key lime pie from Citarella last night. About $4 for a tiny pie. The good news: The filling was the best key lime filling I have ever had. Perfectly tart, with zest in it.... (6 replies, last updated by jenspeed September 19, 2007)

I highly recommend Steve's Authentic Key Lime Pies. They’re made in Brooklyn from fresh, hand-squeezed key limes. I think you can buy them at Citarella, and probably other places, but I have ordered them through the Pie... (4 replies, last updated by Jon July 20, 2004)

I’ve yet to try it but many if not most Key Lime Pies recs I see on this board are for Steve's Authentic Key Lime Pies. They are made in Brooklyn but are available at Citarella’s see the link below. I have been meaning... (14 replies, last updated by Aki November 3, 2004)

In Brooklyn there is Steve's Key Lime pie (in RedHook) look on the outer bourough board or maybe there is a web site. (9 replies, last updated by df November 26, 2003)

The best is Steve's Authentic Key Lime Pie. There’s a shop in Red Hook, but I think the pies are sold in some grocery stores in Bklyn and the city (maybe even Queens). I’d check their website. (7 replies, last updated by lchang June 25, 2007)

I was going to order a Steve's Authentic Key Lime Pie for hubby’s b-day, but I see they no longer ship their pies. Brooklyn is a little too far to travel (esp. on a holiday weekend), but I’m wondering if there is any... (3 replies, last updated by gvogelge July 4, 2008)

Does anyone know of a bakery in San Francisco that makes a great (authentic) key lime pie? Thanks for the help! (0 replies, last updated by JENNYBEEAY January 29, 2008)

You need Steve's Key Lime Pie. I’m attaching a link to purveyors in NYC. I usually pick one up at my local butcher in Brooklyn (Los Paisanos on Smith Street) but it seems they carry them at Citarella as well. Link:... (12 replies, last updated by Caitlin McGrath May 23, 2004)

Steve's Key Lime Pies—link below Link: http://www.stevesauthentic.com/ (3 replies, last updated by Jon June 13, 2004)

Last week I was at Urban BBQ in Rockville. The ribs and sides were great as always. I love their mashed potatoes. What I had for the first time was Key Lime Pie. It was great. I do not know if this was "authentic" or what, but it... (5 replies, last updated by Bill August 14, 2004)

Seconded! Anywhere that has steve's key lime pie has exactly what you want (7 replies, last updated by MargaritaGirl August 1, 2005)