should I find myself eating banana cream pie at M.C.'s which I’ll admit does happen occasionally. Inevitably little traces of the removed meringue remain on the pie. Count me squarely in the whipped cream camp. Meringue... (15 replies, last updated by Jon36 July 20, 2005)

They have an outpost in the Grand Central food court. The sour cream walnut apple pie is delish. (7 replies, last updated by ruth arcone April 17, 2004)

Went to the Hell’s Kitchen location a couple of days ago. It’s a simple little bakery with a sit-down option if you’re interested. I sampled ad their apple walnut sour cream pie to start with, and then tasted a... (2 replies, last updated by kam0424 August 28, 2007)

the pie's at The Little Pie Company are AMAZING! the sour cream walnut apple is out of this world, and the key lime is sublime there’s a branch on 43rd and one on 14th (both are just west of 9th Ave) (3 replies, last updated by elvislives March 26, 2004)

heard about a new book about searching for pie. that begs the questions, where do we go for pie? I know many will mention the apple pan. I like the fresh strawberry and the banana cream. but it’s been a while. (13 replies, last updated by russkar July 2, 2002)

I hate to disagree, But the Little Pie Company is one of the most overrated places in the whole city.. I am not the only one who thinks so. Their crust is the problem. Fairly mediocire. Try the cupcake cafe, They might have some... (5 replies, last updated by jameson April 20, 2003)

Still a chance to make some before the summer stone fruit season is over... My favorite is peach or apricot in the little Emile Henry pie dishes. Enough pie for two. Plus they take less time to cool so you get to eat them faster. (7 replies, last updated by russkar September 25, 2002)

Does anyone know where I can find Boston Cream Pie? A whole cake, not just a slice. So far Gelson’s, Junior’s Deli, Vicente Foods, no luck. Any thoughts? (13 replies, last updated by Jonathan September 6, 2004)

Without a doubt, the one at Jongewaard’s Bake & Broil in Long Beach. I usually don’t care for banana cream pie, but Bake & Broil’s version is truly dreamy. Link: http://www.bakenbroil.com (23 replies, last updated by Mr. Taster June 25, 2004)

I am looking for good coconut cream pie. I looked at an old thread which said Pie Gourmet in Vienna, but the picture on their website of the pie looked very dissapointing very little meringue. I don’t know if the new... (2 replies, last updated by Bob W May 31, 2007)

This is a little late for the 4th, but I like the Coconut (and other) cream pies at Billy’s. (1 reply, last updated by Lucia July 6, 2009)

"The Little Pie Company" makes them with fresh bananas and whipped cream. I haven’t tried this one, but their other pies are very good. They have 3 locations in Manhattan: W. 43rd betw. 9th and 10th Aves.; West 14th Nr. 9th... (10 replies, last updated by masha bousha August 3, 2009)

Looking for a Boston cream pie (or two—enough for 18 people), preferably in midtown. Buttercup doesn’t carry it, and neither does Black Hound or Little Pie Co. Any ideas where I could get this Manhattan? Preferably in... (5 replies, last updated by OrnamentalGravy August 20, 2004)

Date cream pie? Now you’re just tormenting me. I used to order that constantly at the little diner in the town just across the CT river (Charlestown NH). Do I have to road trip to Barre for pies? Petsi needs to expand hers... (4 replies, last updated by Joanie April 5, 2007)

My mother’s birthday is coming up and she loves banana cream pie. Any bakeries you would recommend where you have tried their banana cream pie? (9 replies, last updated by Tatai March 10, 2009)