Let’s dish about everyday cheddars—what’s great, what do you avoid? And, for fun, if you have a favorite eating cheddar (in a higher price range), bring that on, too. FAVORITE EVERYDAY CHEDDARS: - Cabot... (64 replies, last updated by trvler September 18, 2009)

I’m new to the city and was wondering where I could get fresh cheddar. (Cheddar cheese curds would be even better) I’m located near the Brooklyn Museum right now if that can narrow it down a little. (1 reply, last updated by solidgold December 30, 2008)

Anyone know where I can find Cheddar Cheese fried pirogies like the ones they used to serve at Papa Bear on E. 23rd Street? (5 replies, last updated by Speechlass1 March 2, 2008)

My little brother is hellbent on making risotto with this $35-a-pound aged cheddar from the cheese shop by his house. I have never known him to cook anything besides bratwurst — maybe he has a girl to impress? Does anyone... (19 replies, last updated by sweetpotater January 29, 2008)

Can anyone suggest a place to buy real cheddar in Park Slope? I’m just looking for fresh, unpackaged cheese and will be on/around Seventh Ave. later. TIA (0 replies, last updated by efdee May 19, 2001)

i love cheddar cheese. i must say that upfront. i never, never thought i’d find a cheddar i didnt like. but...i bought a wheel of farmhouse cheddar at costco. i felt i ‘owed it’ to ford farm in england to give... (4 replies, last updated by joan March 17, 2003)

I am in Boston for a few days and would like to bring home a good farmhouse cheddar cheese. Can anyone recommend a good cheese shop, preferably close to Copley Square? (2 replies, last updated by StriperGuy November 4, 2003)

I AM TRYING TO FIND A PLACE IN BROOKLYN WHERE I CAN BUY CANADIAN BLACK DIAMOND CHEDDAR; OR IF ANYONE HAS A COMPARABLE CHEDDAR, THAT WOULD BE OK. I DO NOT LIKE HAVING TO TRAVEL TO MANHATTEN FOR CHEDDAR. THANX (6 replies, last updated by paz August 31, 2002)

Catered cheese plates that show up in my dept often contain large wedges of tasty cheddar-blue-cheddar a couple inches thick. Is there a name for this concoction? Not in S&S, Star/Shaws. Where can I get in Boston area? TIA. (2 replies, last updated by ducky March 28, 2007)

I had a cheddar spinach muffin from Clinton Street Bakery and was completely blown away. Does anyone have a recipe that is close to theirs? I love them so much, but live and work too far from there. (2 replies, last updated by sabinaHahn June 6, 2009)

Unable to find Tillamook Sharp Cheddar (red wrapper) in OC for a while now... usually easily gettable at Costco in a 2.5 lb. brick. Anyone have an OC source??? (Doesn’t have to be Costco-sized!) Thanks in advance!!! (15 replies, last updated by Allmodcons July 2, 2009)

I can’t seem to find Tillamook sharp or extra sharp cheddar in the stores anymore. Do any local hounds know where I can find it in Solano or East Contra Costa? (I hope I’m not violating the rules by asking an... (8 replies, last updated by kc72 June 17, 2009)

Best I’ve found is from Cabot Cheese. Haven’t seen it outside their factory store in VT, but you can definitely mail order it: http://www.cabotcheese.com/pages/our_products/products.php?catID=17#Cheddar%20Powder (11 replies, last updated by almansa May 21, 2009)

It’s spring, and the Leafs aren’t in the playoffs yet again. Maybe we need something to cheer, or expound upon. Despite the restrictions on milk marketing and the use of raw milk, we are seeing some pretty darned good... (29 replies, last updated by gooditsall May 23, 2009)

This is almost turning into the quest for the holy grail! Years ago, during the early 90’s I used to work in a popcorn shop in Memphis, TN. The owner, a man named Paul, got his cheese for popcorn in 5 gallon buckets. I do... (6 replies, last updated by torty May 23, 2009)